A 52-year-old man was sentenced Wednesday to 38 years in prison for brutally beating and torturing his 49-year-old brother.
James Naas
“Under our laws, there is no ‘big brother’ or ‘family member’ defense to abuse. This conduct was not mistaken or accidental. It was deliberate, and that is criminal. The fact that it was against a family member is shameful,” said District Attorney George Brauchler. “Of course, Naas forced a jury to impose responsibility on him for a level of violence and sadism that calls out for long-term incarceration. I am glad the years of abuse and violence are finally over for this victim.”
On June 28, 2016, Castle Rock police began an investigation at Adventist Hospital after being notified that a patient there had been assaulted.
The patient initially told officers he had been attacked by strangers. Further investigation revealed the man had been attacked by his older brother for calling the police to report the brother had been destroying his property.
The victim told police his brother, James Naas, had:
• Hit the back of his head with vice grips
• Kicked him in the ribs
• Threatened to pull out his teeth with pliers
• Whipped his back with a metal dog chain
• Put out cigarettes on his face
• Struck his ankle with a hammer
• Cut his leg with a razor
Doctors diagnosed a large cut to the back of the victim’s head, a broken ankle, multiple bruises and cuts on his body, and cigarette burns on his face.
In asking for a 49-year sentence, prosecutors noted that James Naas had abused his brother his entire life.
“This defendant has had a lifetime of exhibiting violence and uncontrollable rage,” said Deputy District Attorney Val Brewster, who prosecuted the case with Deputy District Attorney Dan Warhola. “Even now, from the jail, the defendant classified the beating and torture as a ‘little fight.’ ”
Defense counsel sought the minimum sentence of 25 years.
Judge Stevens sentenced Naas to 15 years in the Colorado Department of Corrections for each of two counts of first-degree assault; and 8 years in DOC for one count of attempted first-degree assault. The sentences will be served consecutively. A one-year sentence for tampering with evidence and a one-year sentence for third-degree assault will be served concurrently.
